Skip to main content
ARTT/FMST 448
Thursday 1.15-5.15
EV 10-785

Erin Manning
with Nasrin Himada and Ronald Rose-Antoinette

Sounds that Move Us, Sounds that Escape Us

In a recent talk given at Concordia (March 2017), poet and scholar Claudia Rankine told a story about a tall black woman waiting in line at the post office. A white man walked ahead of her. The woman at the counter said “sir, the woman behind you was there first.” The white man said “oh! I hadn’t seen her.” The black woman said “you must be in a hurry!” He said “no, I just didn’t see you.” 

This course takes as its starting point the realization that we are always missing things. We are not hearing them. Not seeing them. Not even noticing we are not noticing them. We will ask: what is it that we are missing, and how can we attend not only to the fact that we are missing it, but that there is a politics to what we are (not) hearing, (not) seeing?

Orienting around the sounds of alterity (of the alterity that is the share of our more-than humanness, of the alterity that is black life, of the alterity that is neurodiversity) this course will be an experiment in listening to that which we do not yet know how to hear, or to that which we hear much too clearly (and can’t fathom how others are not hearing it). It is a course that also asks us how we might create conditions for a different kind of hearing, a hearing-with or a hearing-across.

Culling for key texts from the Black Studies tradition as well as texts from indigenous, neurodiverse and queer scholars, we will listen to the interstices between the words and ask not only what else we might be able to hear but what the stakes are when learning begins to include what it works so hard to exclude. We will also listen to each other to hear the differential in the account of what is missing, of what is left unheard.

Finally, we will ask: what is a course without an aim, without a centre? What is a course that needs to tread lightly, to create the conditions for learning rather than knowing the way of learning in advance. Toward these ends, we will have the opportunity to explore, through art and cinema, through philosophy and cultural theory, how else this learning might happen.


TECHNIQUES

This is a course that explores what we cannot hear. Techniques for making felt what is missed in experience will be at the heart of the course.

1      Listening: 1/3 of the class will be marked as listeners for each week. Listening is probably the most important thing we will do in this class. It will be our work to better understand both what it means to listen and what it means to be listened to. Auditors to the class will also be listeners 1/3 of the time (it will be your task to determine when that is).
2     Googledoc: A googledoc will be open and projected during each class. This googledoc is an opportunity for participating in a different way. Listeners can use the googledoc. The googledoc will be archived on the blog week by week.


COURSE SCHEDULE

SEPTEMBER 7

Eric Dyson *audiobook
Tears We Cannot Stop – A Sermon to White America “Inventing Whiteness”

Angela Davis  22 min
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q6Mfgl-5dd4 >> philosophy, hope, imagination

Angela Davis  11 min

Angela Davis  4 min

Amelia Baggs 8.30 min

Reading Out Loud:
Tim Ingold Anthropology and/as Education Chapter 1 – Against Transmission

SEPTEMBER 14

*visiting scholar Denise Ferreira da Silva
Denise Ferreira da Silva Toward a Black Feminist Poethics pp. 81-97

Reading Out Loud:
Sylvia Wynter On Being Human as Praxis “Unparalleled Catastrophe For Our Species?, or To Give Humanness a Different Future,” Conversation with Katherine McKittrick pp. 9-45

Listeners: Olivia, Jennifer, Yannick


SEPTEMBER 21

Fred Moten In the Break Resistance of the Objectpp. 18-66

Reading Out Loud:
Marlon James A Brief History of Seven Killings, chapter 1

Listeners: Matisse, Marco Augustin, Alessandra


SEPTEMBER 28

Naoki Higashida Fall Down Seven Times, Get up Eight Parts 1, 2, 5


Reading Out Loud:
Sparrow Jones Unstrange Minds Autistics Speaking Day
Donna Williams Autism and Sensing: The Unlost Instinct The Everything of Nothing

Listeners: Zachary, Nicolas, Mariana


OCTOBER 5

Nathaniel McKay, From a Broken Bottle Traces of Perfume Still Emanate, pp. 19-21 + pp. 76-78
Amiri Baraka, The Blues Aesthetic and the Black Aesthetic: Aesthetics as the Continuing
         Political History of a Culture, pp. 101-109

listening
Steve Reich, Music for a Large Ensemble

Listeners: Stephanie, Elizabeth, Eloise


OCTOBER 12

Fred Moten In the BreakSound in Florescence pp. 100-148

Listening/watching
Julie Dash, Daughters of the Dust (1991)

Listeners: Anna-Maria, Gregoire, Joshua


OCTOBER 19

Ashon T. Crawley, Blackpentecostal Breath: The Aesthetics of Possibility, Noisepp.
            139-158
Edouard Glissant, Poetics of Relation, pp. 63-75

Watching/listening
Jamilah Sabur, Playing Possum (2012), Moon Tendon (2015)

Listeners: Eli-Bella, Pierre-Luc, Eduardo


OCTOBER 26

Fred Moten In the Break Baldwins Barakapp. 375-418

Reading Out Loud:
Amiri Baraka SOS - Poems 1961-2013 selection tbc
James Baldwin Just Above My head selection tbc

Listeners: Olivia, Jennifer, Yannick

OCTOBER 29EVENT

NOVEMBER 2

*visiting scholar Saidiya Hartman
Saidiya Hartman Lose Your Mother 233pp

*audiotext:
Toni Morrison Beloved Part III

Listeners: Matisse, Marco Augustin, Alessandra

NOVEMBER 9

Fred Moten In the Break Black Moninin the Sound of the Photographpp. 418- 458
Alexander G. Weheliye, Phonographies: Grooves in Sonic Afro-Modernitiespp. 5-10

Reading Out Loud:
Fred Moten and Stefano Harney, The Undercommons pp. 131-136

Listeners: Zachary, Lea, Mariana


NOVEMBER 16

Leanne Simpson The Accident of Being Lost, Songs and Storiesselection tbd

Listening
Leanne Simpson songs

Reading Out Loud:
Thomas King The Inconvenient Indian - chapter 5
Davi Kopenawa The Falling Sky Becoming Other

Listeners: Stephanie, Elizabeth, Eloise

NOVEMBER 23

Fred Moten In the Break Tonality of Totalitypp. 458-505

Reading Out Loud:
M. Nourbese Philip Zong selections tbd
Layli Long Soldier, Whereas, p. 5-15


Listeners: Anna-Maria, Gregoire, Joshua

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Edouard Glissant - Poetics of Relation (some concepts)

Errantry (errance) 18- errantry does not proceed from renunciation nor from frustration regarding a supposedly deteriorated (deterritorialized) situation of origin; it is not a resolute act of rejection or an uncontrolled impulse of abandonment. - The thought of errantry is a poetics, which always infers that at some moment it is told. The tale of errantry is the tale of Relation. 21- The thinking of errancy conceives of totality but willingly renounces any claims to sum it up or possess it. 20- The thought of errantry is not apolitical nor is it inconsistent with the will to identity, which is, after all, nothing other than the search for a freedom within particular surroundings. Rhizomatic thought / rhizome 18- the rhizome- prompting the knowledge that identity is no longer completely within the root but also in Relation. Poetics of Relation 11- each and every identity is extended through a relationship with the Other 20- in the poetics of Relation, one who is erra...

Denise Ferreira da Silva 1 (life) ÷ 0 (blackness) = ∞ − ∞ or ∞ / ∞: On Matter Beyond the Equation of Value

Here are some notes on Denise's text for those interested. Central question: What if blackness referred to rare and obsolete definitions of  matter : respectively, “substance … of which something consists” and “substance without form”? How would this affect the question of value? What would become of the economic value of  things  if they were read as expressions of our modern grammar and its defining logic of obliteration? Would this expose how the  object  (of exchange, appreciation, and knowledge)—that is, the economic, the artistic, and the scientific thing—cannot be imagined without presupposing an ethical (self-determining) thing, which is its very condition of existence and the determination of value in general. On Blackness as disruptive force: activate blackness’s disruptive force, that is, its capacity to tear the veil of transparency (even if briefly) and disclose what lies at the limits of justice. when deployed as method, blackness fractur...

Fred Moten: "Blackness and Nonperformance"